Saturday, October 12, 2013

Verdi: Simon Boccanegra



Transformazione
For legendary tenor Plácido Domingo, this summit among Verdi's dramatic baritone roles has gone from a "maybe someday" dream to a daring experiment slated for the eve of retirement, to, finally, just another role for the (voluminous) books as his career chugs on in its sixth decade. In the same month Domingo celebrates his 70th birthday, two new DVDs document the undertaking, with Sony licensing the February 2010 Met broadcast and EMI the July 2010 Covent Garden. The dual releases are a testament to star power: neither production was new, and both have long been available on DVD with other singers (indeed, the first DVD of Giancarlo del Monaco's Met BOCCANEGRA has Domingo in the tenor role of Gabriele Adorno, c. 1995). If a viewer must choose, it should be an easy call: Covent Garden/EMI boasts a stronger overall cast and a staging with more life and dramatic perception.

On radio or records, this would only be a good BOCCANEGRA. Live in the house or on video, it is...

only 3 stars - namely, Domingo, Gaertner & Levine
A .400 batting average would be great in baseball, but it's disappointing for the Met. Only 2 0f the 5 principal singers reach base in this performance. The amazing Placido Domingo, at the age of 69, sings with undiminished brilliance & intensity, albeit not as a tenor, but in the baritone title role. Also outstanding, both vocally & dramatically, is Stephen Gaertner as Paolo.

But Adrianne Pieczonka shouts her way throughout, often off-pitch, with nary a hint of musical or dramatic nuance; Marcello Giordani often seems unsure of himself & tends to bleat; James Morris's once-magisterial voice sounds tired & threadbare, & he struggles, with difficulty, to get through his great aria, "Il lacerato spirito."

However, James Levine & his magnificent orchestra are, quite simply, magnificent, driving the score with precision, pulse & unflagging energy. The costumes & sets are as sumptuous as the orchestral sound, down to the tiniest details of embroidery & furniture...

Enjoyable show - one miscasting
I enjoyed this video quite well. It would not be my 'desert island' Boccanegra and I don't know if I would return to it often but I was very interested to see and hear Placido Domingo in the title role and I enjoyed him immensely. Of course, you might wish for a bit of a deeper sound in the title role, but the fact that he is 70 years old, and still delivering very satisfying performances is downright thrilling. He is very touching and it is enjoyable to see him in a role where he physically fits the character more than the young, tenor characters we have seen him in, but that don't quite match his physical maturity now.

The miscasting in my opinion was James Morris, whose voice is far from rich an simply isn't low enough to create and exciting Fiesco. Not quite a fiasco of a Fiesco - but dull.

I found Pieczonka very enjoyable with a pretty, easy-to-hear voice. I didn't notice her being off-key as someone else seemed to. Also, I found Giordani in quite good...

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment