Tuesday, October 1, 2013

George Frideric Handel: Messiah (Recorded at Pieterskerk, Leiden, 1993) [Blu-ray]



This is a great performance
I have several recordings and DVDs of the Messiah. This and the Boston Baroque CD are my favorites. There's a pleasant balance between the chorus and the orchestra. The soloists are good and you can make out what they're singing. The setting, King's College Chapel, is beautiful and definitely adds to the performance.

Marvellous performance to watch, poor EMI DVD packaging
This EMI recording is the third Messiah that Cleobury and the King's College Choir have done, made during the 2009 Easter at King's season of concerts. I have reviewed the CD elsewhere, and I think my thoughts about the performance apply to this DVD version as well. As a fan of King's I find this an extremely satisfying recording of the work, and Cleobury and the King's Choir are in fine form as they have always been. Cleobury has the Academy of Ancient Music to play superbly for him, and his soloists are equally fine. However, I must admit there are some small shortcomings that I've noticed in this recording - and these shortcomings are technical weaknesses that have plagued many recent EMI recordings.

Cleobury has had a wonderful musical love affair of the King's College Choir since he started conducting them in 1982. In fact he has built on the superb work of Sir David Willcocks, who made a wonderful all-male King's Messiah for EMI in 1972. When one listens to this...

Warning about the U.S. Blu-Ray Disk of this performance
If there were a zero-star rating I would have awarded it. A warning about the U.S. Blu-Ray Disk of this performance. It will not play on most American Blu-Ray players. Though it is labeled "playable worldwide," it is not true. It is coded at a 50Hz (50i HD) display rate. American HD television and Blu-Ray players are 60Hz. The two formats are incompatible. I live in the U.S. and bought and tested TWO different Blu-Ray disks (both of course labeled "for worldwide playback" including U.S. playback), and though I have two high-end, recent model Sony Blu-Ray players (different models), and know every trick and tweak possible (I am a video and audio professional), I could not get either an image or note of sound from either disk. The "playable worldwide" label is wrong. The disk is not compatible with U.S. system playback. Caveat emptor. You will be disappointed and frustrated if you try to play this disk on a U.S. machine no matter what the label says or the seller assures you. The disk...

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment