Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Die Meistersinger



Meistersinger, Deconstructed.
From my review on Superconductor:
In this production, Ye Olde Nuremberg is reimagined as the arts department at, let's say, Nuremberg Community College. The acts feature a multi-tiered set, with Act I in the library and Act II in the cafeteria. This "Song-school" is run by the Masters and administered by David. Sachs' apprentice (Norbert Ernst) is an academic pedant who spends his time distributing the arcane rules of the Mastersingers in little yellow rule-books. Walther enters this world as the bad-boy artist in leather and shades, painting furiously on musical instruments, the walls, even David himself in his attempts to break out of the old order. He is sung by Klaus Florian Vogt: a pleasing, if smallish tenor that can handle the role's high tetessitura. His good looks recall the late Peter Hofmann.

Hans Sachs (Franz Hawlata) enters as a barefoot, chain-smoking journalist--the rebel within the Mastersinger clique. Mr. Hawlata delivers a solid Sachs, using his...

Dreadful
Just how awful a "conceptual" production can be is amply demonstrated by this travesty of Meistersinger by Katharina Wagner. It is consistent in visual terms. But it bears no relation whatsoever to the work at hand. Indeed it is ridiculous to follow the libretto and attempt the vaguest correlation with what it is being shown on screen. And what we are seeing is ugly and tasteless and pointless. So, Mme. Wagner, off with your head.

Musically, the performance fares better, without being outstanding. But the music is ably sung and it is so beautiful that one can listen with one's eyes closed.

There is some comfort in the knowledge that for once we are given a real live Bayreuth performance even if we are given little of the little ados and fanfares before the performance begins. More could have gone into attempting to create that one is really on the green hill ready to enter the holy of holies. I would have appreciated more Bayreuth flavor. And courtain...

An Imaginative Comtemporary Staging of "Meistersinger!"
Please do not be influenced by the negative reviews of this staging of Meistersinger. The predominant operatic proclivity today ( reinforced by the major opera companies, such as the Met, Vienna State Opera, etc.,) tends to favor traditional stagings in deference to the zeitgiest of the composer favored by the traditionally inclined patrons. Alas, many opera lovers tend to live in the past and seem to be inexorably stuck there. I saw a wonderful avant garde staging of the Ring Cycle at the LA Opera last year that really redefined this masterwork for me. I also love the traditionally staged Ring Cycle but found the LA Opera production to add a new dimension to it from a visual, and intellectual standpoint. Well, Ms. Wagner has accomplished a similar outcome with this latest version of "Meistersinger" at Bayreuth. While I would love this opera in any form, and have several traditionally staged recordings, this particular staging is superb in all aspects and the sound and video...

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment