Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Piano Concertos Warsaw 2010 [Blu-ray]



very interesting juxtaposition of pianists
My first thought was wondering why they didn't use the same pianist for both concerti. But I enjoyed these so much, then I wondered what the results would have been swapping the two combos.

This is a lovely disc. Playing, orchestral contibution and conducting are all beyond reproach. Demidenko is the introspective one with Kissin being the flashier. I really liked the #1. Demidenko is poetic, playful, and treats each note individually. This is a longer concerto than #2 (40min. vs. 24), but it never lags.

Kissin's approach to the #2 (actually written before #1) is more fiery and he exudes much more exhibitionism - good for a concert, perhaps less so over repeated listening. I'll find out, because this is a disc to be played often. The encores are all well done.

The camera work is excellent, not at all intrusive, excellent color balance and saturation ( played on blueray upconverted to 1080p). The sound is likewise about perfect (I used dts, all channels...

Wonderful Chopin Gala concert
For decades and decades, Rubinstein has been the pianist of choice for Chopin, and such was the pre-eminence of the man that it is difficult, even now to disagree . My personal preference though, at least for the two piano concerti, is for the grand dame of piano Martha Argerich. She has recorded these many times, and the two audio recordings that stand out are the 1996 DG recording of the first concerto with Abbado and the LSO (coupled with Liszt's concerto no 1), and the 1999 recording of both concertos 1 and 2 on EMI with Dutoit and the Montreal Symphony. These are seminal performances, and quite indispensable for any collector of Chopin's music.Then came Krystian Zimerman whose amazing DG recording made us hear the concerti with fresh ears and became for many the first preference for these two works, and justifiably so!
This celebratory concert for the 200th birthday of Chopin features the Warsaw Philharmonic led by Antoni Wit, and two superstar Russian pianists, Demidenko...

A sheer pleasure
When you have two Russian pianists of equally great stature but of very different temperament and the premier Polish orchestra under its distinguished music director assembled for a concert in honor of the composer's 200th birthday, you can expect something very special. This it is indeed. The 2010 concert, recorded in excellent (uncompressed, transparent) audio and video in Warsaw's National Philharmonic Hall, surpasses my high expectations. Nikolai Demidenko's technically perfect, introverted and thoughtful approach to the Piano Concerto No. 1 sheds new light onto the score and will make you re-think the work. Evgeny Kissin, dazzlingly emotional and extraverted, brings off the Second Concerto with incredible bravura. Antoni Wit and his Warsaw Philharmonic musicians treat Chopin's (admittedly not highly accomplished) scores with care, finesse and vigor. Theirs is about the most inspired performance of the orchestral parts I have ever heard. There are brilliant encores from the...

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment