Ramey fans, get the 1985 Pesaro DVD
Rossini expert Claudio Scimone conducts this Venetian version of "Maometto Secondo" and if you are only familiar with the original Neapolitan score, the happy ending may come as a bit of a shock--happy, that is for Anna (soprano) and Calbo (mezzo), but not for Maometto (bass).
When the eponymous Turkish sultan comes onstage with his victorious troops for the first time in Act One, he immediately launches into a fiendishly difficult cantabile aria and cabaletta--think of Mehmet II as the Muslim Alexander the Great. In this particular opera, he is engaged in capturing the Venetian colony of Negroponte in Greece. His most famous historical conquest, for us Christians at least, was Constantinople.
In this version, which Rossini modified for Venice's Teatro La Fenice in 1822 (the Venetians insisted on a happy ending), Mehmet II fails to conquer Negroponte because Anna, the woman he loves, betrays him. In order to save her father (tenor), Erisso, the governor of...
Sad, sadder, saddest
This production is, on the whole, musically well performed, with Lorenzo Regazzo outstanding, Gemmabella (as Calbo) excellent, the rest less so; Scimone's musical direction, of course, experienced and confident. However, there are many disappointments in this set for me. First of all, the Venetian version of this opera is the one used here; as a curiosity, interesting to view. . . once, but this revision omits some wonderful music from the original Neapolitan score, and it's obvious Rossini didn't take it seriously, since he simply tacked on the finale of "La donna del lago" for the happy ending the Venetians demanded.
The greatest disappointment of this production is the production itself. The sets are simple and could be effective if the stage director had known what the hell he was doing. I have seldom seen such an inadequate staging anywhere: the whole thing was a mournful dirge, abetted by a lighting scheme that emphasized so much down-lighting that half the time...
A great recording!
The fact that this is a version changed by Rossini to please the Venetians makes it only more interesting. It gives a new rather tragic dimension to the character of Maometto (sung and acted perfectly by Regazzo) and it includes a new trio between Maometto, Erisso and Calbo which is an absolutely stunning waterfall of coloratura (by Regazzo, Mironov and Gemmabella, all experts of it), and makes this "modified" opera a treasure.
The staging is also tasteful - sparse in a modern way, yet the lighting, the costumes inspired by the period, the graceful poses of the singers and the decorations are elegant and caravaggesque. This restrained but rich frame supports the exuberance of the music very well.
Click to Editorial Reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment