buy it
Good performances, excellent sound, great orchestra and hall. Minor problem is shifting of video to different soloists every few seconds. Very distracting but I guess that's necessary to keep the television audience's attention.
A Step Back
The critic, Mr. Kaiser, is knowledgeable about the symphonies and about the past and present culture of his beloved Germany. Mr. Thielemann in the interviews comes across as thoughtful, expressive and easy going, smiling at times, in contrast to his quite serious demeanor on the podium.
The symphony performances seem both classical and romantic. The enclosed booklet states that Thielemann, along with Barenboim and Jansons, "form a vanguard of a counter-movement that seeks to restore to the Classical and Romantic repertory the sort of musical riches and unprecedented expressivity that we associate with a conductor like Wilhelm Furtwangler". This sounds good to me. He is discounting the period practice movement of the last twenty years. He is seeking to compare himself to the performances before 1990. That is exactly what I intend to do. His performances are classical in being relatively small scale (moderately reduced orchestra size) and played in a refined manner...
Powerful Performance
I developed a love of Beethoven in the late 1950's, 1960's and 1970's. I had the original Everest recordings (from 35mm film) with Joseph Krips conducting the London Symphony Orchestra. I wore that set of records out. I just couldn't stop listening to them. I tried to replace them but for some reason the early DVD set of the same recordings lacked the quality of the original vinal records.
In the late 1980s I purchased the symhonies with Georg Solti conducting the Chicago Symphony Orchestra. It was like falling in love all over again. I have high expectations when it comes to Beethoven.
After reading some of the reviews on Amazon I decided it was time to return to Beethoven.
Boy, am I glad I did.
These Blue Ray Format Recordings are fantastic. Thielemann is amazing. It is like falling in love for the first time. They are the same Symphonies, but they are completely new.
I have purchased and listened to all three discs. I...
Click to Editorial Reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment